Skip to main content
 

National Board Certification

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2010-02-23

I currently teach third grade, and I’m a candidate for National Board Certification (NBC) for Generalist/Middle Childhood (7–12 year olds). I would like advice for studying for the Knowledge of Science assessment. I’d also appreciate any other tips for preparing for this certification.
—Lori, Evanston, Illinois

According to the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards (NBPTS) website, the Knowledge of Science exercise for your certification area states: In this exercise, you demonstrate your ability to identify and understand fundamental concepts and principles in science. You are asked to respond to a student’s inquiry about a real-world phenomenon by identifying scientific concepts and principles that are related to the real-world phenomenon. You are also asked to describe an appropriate learning experience with a rationale that will provide student understanding of a concept/principle that relates to the real-world phenomenon.
I don’t have much first-hand experience with the certification process, so I contacted some National Board Certified Teachers for their suggestions.

Amy Fowler Murphy


There is no way to know what specific “real-world phenomena” you will be asked about, but if you have an idea of the possibilities, you will be better prepared. Amy Fowler Murphy from Alabama poses a few questions to consider:

  • What are examples of the “big ideas” in science that your students need to know? Use the National Science Education Standards (NSES) to help you figure this out (click here for a preview)
  • What are some real-world phenomena that relate to these big ideas? Talk to colleagues to help you figure out as many as possible.
  • How would you teach your students about these phenomena in terms of the big ideas? Since inquiry-based teaching methods are encouraged in the NSES and National Board Standards, focus on lessons that allow students to explore the concepts on their own as much as possible. If you use an inquiry format (such as the 5E or 7E model), then your experience as a teacher should allow you to fill in the pieces of the puzzle regardless of the given phenomenon.


Colette Dryden


Colette Dryden from South Carolina agrees that one of the most important things you can do is to understand the NSES. She also suggests identifying big ideas and looking at how your state standards support the NSES and the big ideas. She notes teaching science is not about memorization but about concept development. Ask yourself, “What is the best way to help my students develop the concept?” Inquiry needs to be an integral part of the classroom—not just for National Boards.  She recommends resources such as FOSS (Full Option Science System) or STC (Science and Technology for Children) kits.  Science notebooking as a reflection strategy can strengthen a unit of study. Notebooks should be used for data collection and analysis with you as the facilitator.
In addition to the NSES, Judy Allard suggests you check out the Benchmarks for Science Literacy and the Atlas of Science Literacy for science concepts at the pertinent grade levels.  If this exercise is a portfolio entry, you can choose the phenomenon, and there are lots of tools, such as those in NSTA resources and publications (e.g., Science & Children and the NSTA Learning Center), you could use to devise learning experiences to help students understand the concepts involved. NSTA’s elementary level resources are helpful here, both in devising learning strategies and in deepening your own content background. You might want to read Science Matters (available at the NSTA Store).
Donna Melpolder from North Carolina provides some specific ideas for a response to this exercise: A third-grade student might ask why are there puddles in the yard after it rains. To respond to this, ask the students to explain what might cause this. Record responses on chart paper. The responses would provide insight into the students’ understandings or misconceptions about how water moves through various soils. (Typically the larger the particles, like sand, the larger the pore space and the easier it is for the water to drain through.) Ask the guiding question: How does water drain through different soils? Use three different types of soil–clay, sand, silt. Cut off the tops of three identical 1-liter bottles and put a few holes (same size and location) in the bottom of each. Then fill the bottles with the same volumes of each soil and place the bottle in a container that can capture water after it has passed through each soil.  Using a timer and one cup of water, pour the water in the bottle and time how long it takes for the water to pass through the first bottle. Record the time on a chart.  Repeat it with the other two bottles.  Record other observations, too, such as the appearance of the water. Students could create a bar graph with the collected data. During the discussion ask the following questions: Which soil drained the fastest? The slowest? What does the water look like from the drained soils? Can we change the structure of the soil? Compare the total water quantity that drained with the amount added. Which soil retained the most water after drainage stopped? Why? After discussing their observations about how water drains through the different soils, connect the science lesson to which soil would cause a puddle. You can extend the lesson to investigate puddles on a cement or macadam playground, too.
June Sanders from Georgia recommends the elementary version of NSTA’s Pathways to the Science Standards. Students often ask about rainbows (investigate with a prism), shadows (connect to the movement of the Earth around the sun), and butterflies (relate metamorphosis to the growth and development processes). Jane Lee-Rhodes suggests you practice for this assessment using what your own students have asked about real-world phenomena. Depending on the level of your students, this could be as simple as “Why is the sky blue?” In the response, describe the concepts and principles at the level of adult understanding, and then describe how you would bring those concepts and principles to an appropriate level for your students and justify your choices for the learning experience based on your understanding of how students learn. Be sure to demonstrate an understanding of your students’ backgrounds and experiences as well as their special learning needs.

Jane Lee-Rhodes


Lee-Rhodes also shared her experiences on preparing for the certification:

  • Find a mentor. If there is a NBC cohort in the area, join them. If you can’t meet face-to-face with anyone in your area that you can meet with, seek out an electronic mentor via an email group. As well-meaning and experienced as your other educator friends may be, they probably do not understand the criteria for completing portfolio entries if they have not participated in the process themselves.
  • Organize resource material for your certification area in a notebook. Include information about the specifics for each of your portfolio entries, the tested content, example responses, and a general overview of the process. Get out your highlighter and dig in. It will require a significant time investment.
  • Many people begin with the fourth portfolio entry which relates to your interactions with parents and the community, your professional development, and how you support the professional development of other teachers. At first glance, this might seem to be a place to showcase your achievements and awards, but the focus in this entry is all about how what you do or what you’ve done supports, encourages, and increases student learning. The question my own mentor kept asking me about my activities was “So what?” If I presented workshops for my district, how did that affect student learning? I described how I followed up with teachers who attended the workshop by having them describe how strategies I shared with them influenced student learning in their classrooms.

Lee-Rhodes goes on to describe the NBC process as one of reflection and analysis: what did I do, why did I make the choices I made for instruction, how did those choices play out with my students, did my students reach the learning goals, how did I know they achieved understanding, how did I design follow-up instruction to meet student needs, and what (if anything) would I do differently in the future? NBC is a process, not a single event. The process of analyzing and reflecting on your work with students can result in profound changes to your professional self-image and professional practice. It requires honesty and a “no excuses” approach to evaluate what you do.
I’d like to thank our colleagues for their input. All of them join me in encouraging your efforts in this professional development milestone. If anyone else has additional suggestions, please add a comment!

I currently teach third grade, and I’m a candidate for National Board Certification (NBC) for Generalist/Middle Childhood (7–12 year olds). I would like advice for studying for the Knowledge of Science assessment. I’d also appreciate any other tips for preparing for this certification.
—Lori, Evanston, Illinois

 

Different strokes for different … students

By Debra Shapiro

Posted on 2010-02-23

Creative Commons Different Sides posted to flickr by JP<3!

English-language learners…gifted and talented…female/male…minority…urban…rural…special needs—so many diverse groups of students; so little time to reach them all.
How to do it? One way is by differentiating instruction. Educators with experience in differentiated instruction will share their techniques with you at the NSTA National Conference in Philadelphia.
Here’s a sample of the sessions on this topic (use the Session Browser to find more):

  • Differentiated Science Inquiry (Thursday, March 18)
  • Going Beyond 1,2,3: Successful Differentiated Grouping Strategies (March 18)
  • Differentiating Instruction Related to Science and Societal Issues (Friday, March 19)
  • Developing Differentiated Science Lesson Plans (Saturday, March 20)

And if you’re a school leader, the conference has a session just for you: Differentiated Leadership: Leading With Learning Styles in Mind (March 19). You’ll hear about a way to identify your teachers’ core beliefs so you can craft a differentiated plan for effective leadership. Because different teachers need different strokes, too.

Creative Commons Different Sides posted to flickr by JP<3!

English-language learners…gifted and talented…female/male…minority…urban…rural…special needs—so many diverse group

 

Differentiated instruction

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2010-02-22

Science Scope Cover Feb 2010Consider the facility that students have with electronic communications and games. They somehow had to “learn” how to use these tools and figure out the rules and strategies of the games. But I heard some teachers talking about how “students do not want to learn.” The evidence the teachers had for their statement was their observation that “Students don’t do their assignments.”
But I wonder what the connection is between a student’s desire to learn and the tasks we require of them. How do we choose or design learning activities that will build on students’ prior knowledge, experiences, skills, and strengths while meeting their needs? Do we as teachers ever provide students with any choices or input into what they are learning and how they learn?
Although teachers may provide a variety of activities, several articles in this issue show a structured and systematic design can lead to increased student engagement and learning. Unit Pages: Differentiation for Students describes how students can be scaffolded into taking more responsibility for their learning. Differentiation Through Choice has examples of a strategy called a “think-tac-toe” which provides students with several alternatives to demonstrate their learning. (I’ve also seen this strategy described as a “choice board.”) Check out the websites of Carol Tomlinson  for more on differentiation and Kathie Nunley for more on layered curriculum.

Other articles in this issue describe how to support middle-schoolers as they use inquiry and literacy processes: Getting Students to be Successful, Independent Investigators and Science & Literacy: Tools for Life. Other articles look at the use of commercial video games, visual formative assessments, webquests, photographic scavenger hunts, and how to restructure group  discussions more equitably.
The February 2010 issue of Educational Leadership from ASCD also has several articles related to differentiation. Most require a subscription, but there are two that are available to all: What Research Says About Differentiated Learning and From Apathy to Mastery
And don’t forget that with SciLinks you can find a variety of resources to tap into student interests and skill levels.

Science Scope Cover Feb 2010Consider the facility that students have with electronic communications and games. They somehow had to “learn” how to use these tools and figure out the rules and strategies of the games. But I heard some teachers talking about how “students do not want to learn.” The evidence the teachers had for their statement was their observation that “Students don’t do their assignments.”

 

A strand of pearls

By Debra Shapiro

Posted on 2010-02-19

Are you an urban or rural educator seeking pearls of wisdom for engaging your students? Plan to attend the NSTA National Conference in Philadelphia. The conference will give you those “pearls” through a strand of sessions entitled Meeting the Unique Needs of Urban and Rural Learners.
High school teachers, pick up some classroom and field activities and see how you can help urban students make the connection between their local environment and weather conditions (Thursday, March 18). Teach chemistry? Learn how urban high school teachers used a Professional Learning Community (PLC) to boost students’ chemistry participation (also taking place on March 18).
Elementary teachers, have any budding engineers in your classroom? Come to Philly and hear about some strategies for integrating standards-based, interdisciplinary engineering activities your urban students will enjoy (Friday, March 19). Middle level educators, find out how to use interactive notebooks to inspire your urban and rural young scientists, and even create your own version (Saturday, March 20).
And don’t miss featured speaker Garland L. Thompson on Saturday. In his Shell Science Seminar, Talent Knows No Color Line, this noted television commentator, law professor, and reporter will share his experiences selecting STEM competition winners who have “scaled hurdles our society says are insurmountable.”

Are you an urban or rural educator seeking pearls of wisdom for engaging your students? Plan to attend the NSTA National Conference in Philadelphia.

 

Going green

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2010-02-15

TST cover Feb 2010Teachers use several strategies at the end of the school year. One strategy is to try to cram in as many topics as possible in an effort to “cover” everything.  Other teachers use culminating or capstone projects to integrate concepts and give students a chance to use what they’ve learned in science (and other subjects). Environmental investigations are a natural for these projects. The projects described in this issue highlight the students’ research questions and how they share the results of their authentic investigations:
The “Green” Root Beer Laboratory demonstrates an activity to promote environmental awareness in the classroom along with questions about consumerism, recycling, advertising, sources of food products, and nutrition. And it results in a useful product!
Investigating Aquatic Dead Zones incorporates concepts from chemistry and physics in a water study. SciLinks has additional information and suggestions in the collection of links for Ocean Pollution.
I went to a session at the 2008 NSTA conference in Boston by the authors of The Urban Green Tree Project. I was impressed then by the potential for this project, and it was interesting to see what this “looks like” in a real school.

After digging out of 30+ inches of snow here in the Northeast The CORALS Connection looks like a tropical topic. SciLinks has more resources on Coral Reefs. Current maps of snow depths or other weather conditions show that on February 14, every state in the continental US had some snow cover!!).
Many of these projects, including the field ecology course described in Meet Us Outside! could be implemented as a supplemental summer term project, too.  All of these authors provide suggestions for how (and why) to incorporate these investigations into a busy schedule. The projects described in this issue are authentic inquiry/research projects related to environmental topics. You may also be interested in activities in the February issue of Science and Children, in which younger students investigate local watersheds and soils.
Encyclopedia of Earth may look like a blog or wiki, but according to the article in this issue, it’s a peer-reviewed work based at Boston University and operated in partnership with the National Council for Science and the Environment with articles written by reputable authors. Many articles have been individually added to SciLinks, but the entire, searchable site is a valuable resource.
If you’re reading this, you already know about blogs. Create a Classroom Blog looks at blogs as way of sharing and interacting among students, using an authentic technology tool. For example, in a class I observed, the teacher created a blog for students to add their reflections, comments, summaries, or conclusions about their projects and investigations. The students could read what others posted, and the teacher could add comments right to the document. The article has suggestions for sites to host blogs at no cost. Unfortunately, blogs are blocked in some schools. I’m curious about that: Shouldn’t the teacher have a say in what resources are (or are not) available to them?
Regardless of the grade level you teach, bookmark the NSTA Portal: Safety in the Science Classroom with lists for secondary and elementary schools. Many of these resources are also in SciLinks topic Safety in the Science Classroom. Check out the  Connections for this issue. Even if the article does not quite fit with your lesson agenda, the authors provide handouts, background information sheets, data sheets, rubrics, or examples of student work that may give you some ideas. And NSTA Recommends has more resources related to climate change and “teaching green.”

TST cover Feb 2010Teachers use several strategies at the end of the school year. One strategy is to try to cram in as many topics as possible in an effort to “cover” everything.  Other teachers use culminating or capstone projects to integrate concepts and give students a chance to use what they’ve learned in science (and other subjects).

 

The Great Backyard Bird Count: Community science in your backyard or schoolyard

By Peggy Ashbrook

Posted on 2010-02-12

Bird counts involve children in citizen science projects where a greater community contributes to the data used by scientists to understand bird behavior and more. The Great Backyard Bird Count is happening now and counting can take place through Monday, February 15th, so there is still time for your students to participate.

This annual four-day event is led by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology and National Audubon Society, with Canadian partner Bird Studies Canada and sponsorship from Wild Birds Unlimited. Gathering data over many years makes them more meaningful. The shortest length of observation that can be submitted is just the right amount of time for young children—15 minutes! And, you do not have to be outside to count. Counting from a window is perfectly acceptable and “Your counting always counts!” Visit the Great Backyard Bird Count at www.birdsource.org/gbbc/ and learn how your students can contribute data.
I’ll let you know what I see tomorrow. There are plenty of Mourning Doves, House Sparrows, Blue Jays, Northern Cardinals, and Black-capped Chickadees around even with all the snow we’ve had in the last weeks.
Peggy

Bird counts involve children in citizen science projects where a greater community contributes to the data used by scientists to understand bird behavior and more. The Great Backyard Bird Count is happening now and counting can take place through Monday, February 15th, so there is still time for your students to participate.

 

Science in the community

By Mary Bigelow

Posted on 2010-02-08

S&C cover Feb 2010I’m hoping that secondary teachers will take a look at the articles that describe authentic investigations conducted by young scientists in their communities: Creative Soil Conservation and Boulder Creek Study. The latter has examples of student work as they studied the water quality in their communities, using various indicators, including the presence of aquatic invertebrates. The authors noted that their students did not have much background in the topic of a “watershed.” If your students need this information also, use the keyword watershed in SciLinks. SciLinks also has websites with information and activities on topics related to soil for grades K-4 and 5-8 (e.g. types of soil, soil erosion, microorganisms in soil).
From hurricanes to earthquakes, forest fires mudslides, and record-setting snowstorms and rainfall, children often ask “Can it happen here?” Three articles are related to this topic. Along with Can We Protect Our Communities From Natural Disasters?,  check out the SciLinks keyword disasters for grades 5-8. Even if you’re not in an earthquake zone, activities such as those in Shake It Up and The Built Environment tap into the creativity of future engineers. SciLinks has lists of related websites on the topic of earthquake resistant structures and the science of bridges. One of my favorites is Building Big: All About Bridges from PBS.

If you like the ideas in the article How It’s Made, SciLinks has more information on pencils (5–8).  Action Figures describes how to hook students into a study of the skeletal system. Even though my curriculum did not include human anatomy, I learned that a brief review of the human skeleton helped students to connect to the skeletons of other vertebrates. In SciLinks, search for bones (5–8) or skeletal system (5–8), which includes other systems of the body. Three examples include Bird Skull Collection, the Mr. Bones interactive puzzle, and Virtual Body, which is also available in Spanish
To extend your activities on growing seeds, check out From Mystery Seed to Mangrove Island (I wonder what other variations on the mystery materials teachers who do not live in Florida can come up with!) and The Farmer in the Lab, which makes the investigation more complex and challenging for older students.
Many teachers are looking for ideas to integrate science with other content areas. It’s challenging to keep the project focused on a theme or essential question, rather than merely putting together a collection of “activities.” Living Off the Land dispels some of the misconceptions children have about Native American cultures as they focus on the relationships between people and natural resources. Outdoor Classrooms has suggestions and resources to use a corner of the schoolyard, a window box, or an outdoor center. And check with a local rescue or rehabilitation center if you have students similar to the Turtle Girls and want to give them ownership of their project.
I’m going to reread Using Learning Progressions to Monitor Progress Across Grades. I wonder how this way of assessing students in science processes is interpreted in schools where science takes a back seat to test prep in reading and math? I’m also curious as to how students beyond grade 4 would “score” on this. This article has related resources in the Connections for this issue, along with ideas for handouts, background information sheets, data sheets, rubrics, for several of the other articles.

S&C cover Feb 2010I’m hoping that secondary teachers will take a look at the articles that describe authentic investigations conducted by young scientists in their communities: Creative Soil Conservation and

 

Footprints in the snow&#8212;books to extend learning

By Peggy Ashbrook

Posted on 2010-02-07

bird footprints in fresh snow, under the feeder

Bird footprints in fresh snow

With 18 inches on the ground, and another 2–4 inches of snow due Tuesday, is it any wonder I’m thinking of how to make the most of this unique material in school? When we get back to school we’ll look for signs of animal activity and read to learn how animals live in the snow.

Earlier in the week (before the fourth snow day this year—now we’re up to six) I read a book about animals who live in the snow with groups of 4-10 children:

Who Lives in the Snow? by Jennifer Berry Jones, illustrated by Consie Powell (Roberts Rinehart Publishers, 2001).

The detailed ¾ cut-away pictures allow readers to look under the snow and see what animals are doing. The children enjoyed pointing to and counting the animals, asking about the animal names, and talking about what animals they are familiar with. The weasel was a new one for my East coast city kids but they did recognize the fox. Some groups of preschool children will want to hear the entire text on each page but most will be happier with less. Each time you read it the children will want a little more. The information is fascinating and the glossary helps with new terms. Did you know that the vole uses a network of tunnels under the snow and that snow can actually flow like water?

I’m eager to read another book, Under the Snow by Melissa Stewart, illustrated by Constance R. Bergum  (Peachtree Publishers, 2009), which has a similar theme but introduces some different animals. The publisher offers a simple, appealingly silly, Readers’ Theater script at http://peachtree-online.com/pdfs/UndertheSnowRT.pdf.

Children may be more familiar with what traces of animal activity they see on top of the snow. They enjoy finding footprints in snow, mud, or sand and guessing who made them. I made fake dinosaur footprints in the snow and the children noticed them (but nobody was fooled).

Mystery Animal Tracks: A photo riddle book by Kelly Barnhill (Capstone Press, 2010) introduces tracks with a human example and then gives text clues to the owner of each footprint before revealing the animal that made it on the next page. The text clues only work if the children have some familiarity with the animal so you can omit them or skip the misleading ones such as “Backwards Bounder” for a rabbit. It’s unfortunate that the raccoon was labeled a “bandit” with the markings of a “robber’s mask”. But the photos of footprints in place show how the animal moved in addition to the shape of their feet. You can wonder aloud, “I wonder why (this animal) has big/small/padded/hoofed feet?” to begin a conversation about how feet function.

Your children may enjoy making handprints and footprints in playdough indoors after exploring what prints they can find or make outdoors in snow, sand, or mud.

Peggy

bird footprints in fresh snow, under the feeder

Bird footprints in fresh snow

 

What are you doing with your wiki?

By Debra Shapiro

Posted on 2010-02-05


Wikis have been called “the quintessential collaborative tool.” In this article from the February 2010 issue of NSTA Reports, you’ll find out how teachers around the country are using wikis to collaborate with colleagues around the world, as well as to communicate with students and parents.
Do you have a wiki? Tell us about yours, and how you use it to enhance your teaching.

 

The Frugal Science Teacher, PreK&#8211;5

By Claire Reinburg

Posted on 2010-02-05

When the going gets tough, the tough get creative. Challenging times mean lean budgets in many schools, but science teachers have a knack for stretching resources to keep students engaged in lively educational activities even in a pinch. Editor Linda Froschauer presents a timely compendium of resources from NSTA Press books and NSTA journals in a new book titled The Frugal Science Teacher, PreK–5: Strategies and Activities. If you’re in need of budget-conscious classroom activities or just new ideas and strategies, you’ll find lots to choose from on topics from student-created constructions to instructional strategies that maximize the science budget. Froschauer says in her introduction, “You may not save hundreds of dollars a year by following the recommendations found in this book. You will, however, find creative ways to keep expenses down and stretch your funds while building student understanding.” We’ve posted a free sample chapter the Science Store:   See “Materials Repurposed: Find a Wealth of Free Resources at Your Local Recycling Center.”

When the going gets tough, the tough get creative. Challenging times mean lean budgets in many schools, but science teachers have a knack for stretching resources to keep students engaged in lively educational activities even in a pinch.

Subscribe to
Asset 2